“… so he blessed him.”
In this study I ask what might appear to be strange questions, but please bear with them, for they are asked in all seriousness. When is a lie a lie? Can it ever be ‘craftiness’? Christians are very good at accepting the idea of holiness, etc., but they seem to forget that there are times when we must act craftily and with subtlety. Try as we might, we cannot get rid of this fact.
In another study I have asked how this command by God differs from, say, the ‘disinformation’ spread at times of war. Is this a ‘lie’ or is it mere craftiness? This chapter presents us with what appear to be blatant lies on the part of Rebekah and Jacob. Yet, what would have happened if Esau had received both his birthright and the final blessing from his father? Would the line of holiness from Abraham be broken? (Of course these are rhetorical queries, for God cannot allow His plans to be diverted or thwarted by the plots or actions of mere men).
No, this would be impossible, for God’s will must be done. He predestined the line to remain unbroken, so that it was safe. But, it was unbroken by way of subterfuge! Was this legitimate? Or, was it a lie?
We think of other similar instances of subterfuge that brought about God’s plan. For example, when Jael drove a six inch tent peg through Sisera’s brain, was it murder, or was it a legitimate action of war? Interpretation can sometimes be hard and might even offend our cherished views. That is how it must be.
If, say, we believe that all killing is wrong, then we will view any killing in scripture as wrong. But, in many instances it was God Himself Who ordered the deaths of people, sometimes in their thousands. The same critics would similarly reject the death penalty. But, their beliefs are false, for God clearly says in the Decalogue that it is murder that is condemned, not ‘killing’ per se. Was Sisera’s death ‘murder’, or was it obedience to God, even if such obedience is unwitting?
When David told an untruth to Saul to save his life, was it a subterfuge or was it a lie? When Rebekah and Jacob did what they did – was it a lie, or was it something else? To me, it seems like a lie. But, is it? If it was within God’s plan how could it be called wrong? Or, was it within God’s plan? We have no way of knowing the final answer, so we must consider the facts and interpret accordingly. It is not as easy as some might have us believe.